The f* word
Contributed by Yumna Al-Adeimi, Canada   
Friday, 01 December 2006
Islam Feminism.gifMeet the new f* word: feminist. 

 The label feminist has always been a touchy word that generally invokes negative connotations. Over the years it has been used as a way to provoke, and perhaps insult people who are concerned for the rights of women. 

 Many women and men unfortunately define a feminist as an angry, over-thinking, bitter, and undesirable woman who blames society and men for her own shortcomings.   But that’s putting it nicely.  For example, one male identified feminists as “fat and ugly” who “nobody likes” so she “joins a group to bitch about everyone’s rights”.  Such an opinion is ignorant at its best. 

History and religion are saturated by male interpretations; women are demeaned by individuals, and systemically oppressed by institutions.  But unfortunately some men don’t understand women and sadly do not have an interest in understanding women or their concerns.  Some men ascribe to the popular notion that women are from Venus thus losing interest in actively taking time to identify with women. This attitude in itself can never be described as one the noble Prophet took.  But sadly this attitude is played out in the token representation of males in university classes and Islamic lectures about women.  Men are difficult to find in lecture halls when topics focus on the rights, histories, contributions, and oppression of women.  Would that be the case if the lecture was about the obedient wife?  Certainly, the same can be said about women – many more will attend a lecture about ‘how to be an obedient wife’ rather than a lecture which questions the traditional notions defining a woman by what she must and must not do. 

 Lacking an understanding, some people use the word feminist as an insult to diminish a woman’s credibility.  Being anti-feminist is sometimes equated to being pro-Islam, which is truly a dishonour to the feminism within Islam; a feminism that has given women unparalleled rights. 

 Academics and activists have spent years shaping, understanding, and living the various forms of feminism.  Within these various articulations of feminism, there are three grounding common principles shared by Radical, Liberal, Socialist, Third wave, and Islamic feminists:

  1. Women are human beings.
  2. Therefore they deserve to be treated decently (like any other human being).
  3. And if they are treated as inferior, it’s due to socially-constructed factors and not their biology.

 These principles easily fit the humanist and Islamic way of thought, which are shared even by those who do not understand feminism.  Of course there are significant differences in the way feminism is expressed, but these underlying principles are at the core of feminist thought. 

 Lucretia Mott once said, “in the degradation of women the very fountains of life are poisoned at their source”.   And we have seen this reality played out whether women are degraded in the east or the west.  This has largely been the result of failing to realize the struggles of women, and misunderstanding the purpose of feminism.

 Perhaps these confusions can be elevated if we educate ourselves about feminism.  Maybe then we can assertively make an educated conclusion whether to use feminism as the f* word, or as a term to label those concerned for the expanding half of this world: women.

On Feminism:

 Lectures: Shaykh Abdullah Adhami: www.sakeenah.org
The empowerment of women in Islam - Islam and feminism - The nature of women: Part I, Part II, Part III

 Book: A vindication of the rights of woman. By Mary Wollstonecraft

 Article: Liberal, Socialist, and Racial Feminism: An introduction to three theories about women’s oppression and social change.  By Shana L. Calixte, Jennifer L. Johnson, and J. Maki Motapanyane

 


Views: 2034

  Comments (15)
 1 Written by Guest, on 02-12-2006 21:39
I think that you are a feminist and you don't know it! And I mean the bad one not the one you just described. You battered men to death with this article calling them uneducated and inexperienced, You think that's the best way to get men's approval for your little feminin thingy!?
 2 F*minism
Written by Guest, on 03-12-2006 09:04
Was feminism there before 1400 years from now?!. 
 3 ta3qeeb
Written by Guest, on 03-12-2006 09:50
I just meant to know the birth and the life stage of feminsim. 
A>D
 4 Nagib Al-Udaini
Written by Guest, on 03-12-2006 14:46
"History and religion are saturated by male interpretations" 
(Anti feminist = Pro Islam) 
What does the writer wants here?!! 
All prophets were males, All major scholars were males (Ahamd ibn hanbel,Shafii,etc). The Quran mentioned in many occasions when taking a testimony or being a witness, there should be 2 men or 2 women and one man, is the Quran anti feminist!!? Do you think Fatima bent Muhammad (Radia Allah anhaa) will think this way? Are you going to be better than her? 
I?d say "Repent to Allah"  
 
 5 Re:Thank you for this article
Written by Guest, on 04-12-2006 02:39
Jazak Allah kheran for comments. 
First of all, I know that there is no defamation to Islam or Quran in the article and it better not be.  
I guess you didn?t get my point.  
After I read the article, I was questioning and wanted to awaken the writer by giving some examples from the history and Quran.  
Unfortunately, many muslim men & women might get excited by some of the feminists views while they have a weak Islamic foundation. They easily can go astray like what happened to Amena Wadood. 
Many of us who live in the west (including myself) have limited knowledge about Islam and the Islamic history. Though, we might adopt and stand for some views that don?t correlate with our prophet?s teachings (pbuh). 
.  
Nagib
 6 Written by Guest, on 04-12-2006 07:44
Akhi Nagib, 
 
I think you should quote the entire thing before commenting. 

Being anti-feminist is sometimes equated to being pro-Islam, which is truly a dishonour to the feminism within Islam; a feminism that has given women unparalleled rights. " 
 
The write states in this sentence that those who equate anti-feminism with pro-Islamism are wrong, and they are dihonoring the feminism and the many rights given to women by Islam... 
 
Please please, let's be more cautious about giving advice that could be taken out of context. The writer did not in anyway say being pro-Islam = being anti-feminism is an opinino she agrees with. I'd be glad if you can show me otherwise :-) 
 
Oz
 7 Umm...
Written by Guest, on 05-12-2006 02:45
Such an irritating word. I've always hated this F* word, and the other illogical word "Male Society". Why label is for God's sake, aren't we all drowning in the same injustice, particularly in our middle eastern countries? It never made sense to me and it seems like it never will.  
 
 
Taima.
 8 Issmat A.
Written by Guest, on 06-12-2006 17:02
I am with Maryam 1000 and 1%. I think you have described the situation very accurately and intelligently. I would have you on my jury over 10 men who think that they, by virtue of their gender alone, are superior to women in thought and capacity. 
 
I would also add that the reversion (perfect word for this situation, by the way) to pre-Islam habits and traditions regarding the role of women in society is not only the result of colonialism. I believe that it was the natural path our societies would have ended in anyway. The regression started, as you mention, as early as 50 years following Mohammed's death (SAW). There was no colonialism at that time.  
 
So let's stop trying to find excuses for our own ignorance and hanging our guilt on the forks of religion, the west, aliens, etc. Empowerment begins from within. Don't raise/treat the women in your family as inferior beings, Instead, afford them every opportunity for education. Give them every venue for personal and professional advancement. Let them know that they are valued, equal citizens and that their opinion is NOT worth half of yours. What a ridiculous thing to say anyway! Would you take the testimony of 10 uneducated male villagers over that of one female Chartered Accountant when it comes to a case involving your company's market value of preferred shares?) 
 
This is a great topic. We need more of it. Locally-branded Feminism is a long time coming to Yemen and the Arab word. We should support every initiative of anyone who wishes to instigate change whether they?re writing articles, forming organizations, or involving in public or private activism in or out side their home. 
 
Issmat A. 
 
P.S. If you would like to discuss my comment in private, please feel free to write to issmat_a at hot mail dot com.
 9 Yasmeen
Written by Guest, on 06-12-2006 20:59
I say nuke all them sinful women they're stealing our eternal thunder. They asked for equality we [men] gave them the right to birth control (conditionally) and the right to pick what to cook for lunch. aish 'ad yshto? dakhlnah, dakhal bihmaroh 
:P 
P.S. in a very low voice, with a racing heart I wonder, Issmat, aren't there many verses in the Quran that use masculine pronouns even when they're addressed to men and women?
 10 Written by Guest, on 06-12-2006 23:27
Why don't both of you guys just add each other on msn and have your little chit-chats over there! That way you will save us your rather ridiculous questioning of the Quraan and Prophet's (pbuh) sayings. It is youg men and women like yourself that introduce rebelion amongst less educated pupils. Because beleive me, if anyone knows how to read and write, they wouldn't even finish reading your long comments.
 11 Written by Guest, on 07-12-2006 00:04
I wrote a long reply to my friends Yasmeen and Ismaat regarding "questioning" traditional religious literature. Do you guys (mods/interested parties) want me to post these replies on the YSAA, since they might seem a bit irrelevant to the author's article?  
 
Thank you :-) 
 
Osama
 12 Issmat A.
Written by Guest, on 07-12-2006 02:11
Hi Osama, 
 
You are right. The comments are beginning to turn into a conversation more fit for a forum. I don't mind continuing on YSAA.  
 
And to the annonymous guest with his pearls of wisdom, if you have nothing pleasant or useful to say, then you don't need to clutter the comment box. This space is for people who want to intelligently engage in post-article discussions that may or may not express an array of agreeable and non-agreeable opinions. That's how minds are stimulated, information is shared, and ideas are born. If you wish to disagree with some of the opinions I am expressing regarding this article, please feel free to respond in kind. A little bit of verbal jousting is expected on these things, and welcomed. But please, no need for personal attacks. 
 
Yasmeen, I had similar thoughts about the use of masculine form in the language of the Quran. Without any form of proper research, my opinion at this point is that the reason is because Allah is talking to Mohammed in most of the Quran, and so his directions of "do this and say that" are directed to the masculine, i.e the Prophet (PBUH). Although, there could be some cases where that is not true and the masculine form is used regardless. Which, in my opinion, means one of two things:  
1. People who wrote the Quran (or atleast compiled it - Othman era?) used masculine forms, intentionally or unintentionally, since they were men. (Blasphemy) 
 
2. Allah actually intended to use teh masculine form, and since we know that everything in the Quran is done with wisdom behind it, perhaps there is truth to the belief that Islam and Allah see men in a different light than women. Then the question is, is the differentiation out of preference? Or is it to indicate more responsibility? A combination of the above, or other reasons? I don't have the answer to that. These are just my speculations. 
 
Cheers to all. 
 
Issmat  
 
 13 Yasmeen
Written by Guest, on 07-12-2006 04:19
Thanks Osama for your thorough response. I may not be able to post anything for a couple of days but I took the discussion to YSAA. It's less formal and I gather some of you are more comfortable there. 
If anyone is still interested in this you can join us in YSAA under New Topic: Continuation of discussions initiated in Shabab Yemeni,Dec06 
 14 The point is:
Written by Guest, on 08-12-2006 18:24
To be honest, I couldn't read all the comments above, but since Quran is mentioned somewhere in here I want to point out that if you read the Qur'anic verses you will find the word "Insan" oftenly repeated throughout the book. Does that mean Allah was only speaking to men and not women? How about if you know He spoke to both of them using that one word "Insan", and that in the Arabic language you can't refer to a female as "Insanah" but "Insan"? 
 
 
Women and men are both humans at the end, none of them could survive without the other, their existance depends on each other, they are one entity. Labeling their needs and rights makes no sense, it creates differences, and it divides them instead of bringing them together. Labeling it doesn't serve the cause. It is not us versus them. That is the point.  
 
 
Taima
 15 Interesting Statistics
Written by Guest, on 03-01-2007 17:12
I must say that the statistics that you have provided are interesting. However, it would be more credible if you had provided a URL link as a reference.

Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.2