Ignorant but Opinionated
Contributed by Yumna Al-Adeimi   
Friday, 01 September 2006

Ignorant But Opinionated - girl with headscarfWeddings should always be about the bride.  Her glittery Pantene hair; her natural shades of make-up; her snowy white dress; it’s always about the bride unless something drastic happens.  Like, say a hijab-clad woman enters an all-non-Muslim wedding.

Some people wonder what you’re doing there and immediately want to know who invited you, perhaps out of curiosity or perhaps so they can sigh in relief.  Also, because people will be politically incorrect, thanks to subconscious-awakening tongue-loosening alcohol.

Recently, I attended a wedding ceremony of a close non-Muslim friend.  Her family, who is well-cultured, ensured there was vegetarian food and virgin drinks.  Naturally, I bumped into some people with a good sense of humour, like the nice guy who asked “would you prefer alcohol that doesn’t taste like alcohol?”

I expected curious questions, and I was asked.  But what I wasn’t expecting was ignorance. I’m always up in arms about ignorant Muslims who have an opinion.  But I realized, outside the bubble of ignorant Muslims there are also equally ignorant non-Muslims, who unfortunately, also have opinions, like the beautiful educated woman who momentarily sat beside me at the wedding.  Just a FYI, she has cared for patients from all walks of life for over 15 years.

“So tell me… why would someone like you cover up so much?” she pointed to my hijab and long-sleeved top. I got excited for a moment because I thought she was looking to enrich her mind with an answer.

Alas, that was not the case.

She completed her ‘question’ with “You got married and your husband wants you to wear it, right? So other men can’t check you out.”  I couldn’t help hide my woman-are-you-cuckoo face.   “Oh. No? It must be your father.” she corrected herself.

I had to say something at this point before she really offended me and tells me that Bin Laden, my husband of 10 years, ordered me and my five invisible young daughters to “cover up so much”.

“Um, you’re way off”.  I smiled.  “I’m not close to being married, and no, my parents had nothing to say about my decision to wear the scarf”.

Then she pulled her chair closer and looked me in the eye.  I stared back.  She asked how long.  I answered.  Then she sighed, “You know… for us here it’s hard to understand why someone like you would choose to cover everything up”. “’Us’ who.” I said, but I wasn’t asking.  Just subtly letting her know if “us” is Canadian, then that would include me.

She took another sip from her glass, leaned back and said, “It adds so much mystique… it doesn’t hide beauty if that’s what it’s supposed to do”.

“It’s a statement”.  I said.

“A statement?” she frowned in puzzlement.

“Yes, a statement about who I am.  What I believe in.  I’m letting you know what you can expect from me.  And also, what I am expecting from you”.

“Now that’s interesting.  So tell me… what’s your ethnic background?”  I told her my background of halves and when I said Arab, she touched my hijab and asked “So this is from your Arab side?” I began to wonder if she worked at a hospital where Muslims were banned.

“No, this is my Muslim side”.  I answered.

“So help me figure this out.  Muslims are what exactly? Because there are Arabs and they all cover up and what about…?”

God have mercy.  The lovely and perhaps embarrassed couple sitting beside us interrupted her, excused themselves, and asked if the woman investigating my hijab would join them.  She said it was a pleasure to meet me.

I was stunned and worried.  A woman of her education and experience had a strong opinion about Muslims, but didn’t know the difference between ‘Arab’ and ‘Muslim’.

I wonder if this opinionated woman ever participated in the poll revealing that 45% of Canadians and 78% of the French think it is necessary to ban the hijab due to “concerns about Islamic extremism” [1].

Rather than rectifying ignorance with open-minded questions, this woman nourished it with stereotypes while 45% of Canadians nourished it with an opinion.   How comforting.

I would rather people ask stupid questions than assume. I would rather people ask me if I’m bald or simply ask ‘why’?  But if they choose not to ask, I would hope they not assume on my behalf.  Because that’s what ‘oppressed’ hijab-clad women like me, call ignorance.

 

References
1.   http://pewglobal.org/reports/display.php?PageID=811

 

 


Views: 1432

  Comments (14)
 1 Good Answers
Written by Guest, on 01-09-2006 21:21
I loved your answers to her questions. Seems like that woman was totally blind and knew nothing about Islam. She doesn't have to, BUT she shouldn't have blab about sth she IGNORES... 
 
Mona Qasem
 2 LOL
Written by Guest, on 01-09-2006 21:23
Funny grammar... got the point? :grin  
 
Mona
 3 Bashar
Written by Guest, on 04-09-2006 09:14
Yumna you very butfule in your hjab > i love you that and you in the right way to troth
 4 Theirs and ours
Written by Guest, on 04-09-2006 19:49
Thanks for the insights Yumna. 
 
Reading the article made me wonder, how much do Muslims really know about other religions. I wonder if there is an Arabic educational system where Judaism and Christianity are discussed. We ask others to learn about our religion ?. but shouldn?t we also learn about theirs!! 
 
 
Sahar 
 5 mashallah
Written by Guest, on 11-09-2006 16:40
well done yumna i cant say anymore...trust me...i have seen worse cases..where they ask me why am i hiding my beauty for when i tell them the reason they think is sick...whats the point when show up and be like the non muslim ...ignorance is everywhere
 6 oh yeah
Written by Guest, on 11-09-2006 16:42
the grammer was short but i got what u ment lol 
 
khady
 7 Written by Guest, on 12-09-2006 18:30
Expected questions ... 
Your answers show a strong belief in wearing the scarf, and that should have an impact on these ignorant people 
:-)
 8 Written by Guest, on 13-09-2006 08:44
well, it is good she asked (even if she wasn't trying to understand)! Many ppl will just ‎keep such ignorant opinions for themselves and go on acting upon them as if they were ‎facts! She got to hear you, and your statement was clear!‎ 
 
On a side note, I would like to express my great respect to the sisters that chose to wear ‎hijab while they could just forget about it and mix in the crowd like everybody else! We ‎men can do that easily, most of the time! It is really a wake up call seeing a sister wearing ‎hijab minding her business when visiting a non-Muslim country. It is a constant reminder ‎of who one is and what he believes in!‎ 
 
fee aman Allah!‎ 
adeeb 
 9 Pain
Written by Guest, on 13-09-2006 10:47
nice conviction, but if you are wearing it to stop men from looking, Muslim men should wear camel blinds (the ones they put for camels to go around water wells ect.) This should reduce sin factor by 50%. 
 
I also think red scarfs are less religious than black ones also how about the muslim wearing hijab and very tight everythig else? How deep is the conviction? Little questions before we decide to complement each other of increadible stands. 
 
 
Pain :grin :grin
 10 "No Fatwa, please!" :)
Written by Guest, on 13-09-2006 11:15
?Yes, a statement about who I am. What I believe in. I?m letting you know what you can expect from me. And also, what I am expecting from you?. 
 
so Pain :) 
, where do you "stand"? 
 
Adeeb
 11 Pain
Written by Guest, on 13-09-2006 16:18
Mr. Adeeb is eager to wear a Hijab it seems....any color in particular ? :grin On a serious note though general conviction that women MAKE MEN SIN (are men so not trust worthy?)so let's make women be less appealing is the only solution eh? Anyone can comment I am just bringing different sides to the discussion. 
 
 
Pain
 12 Written by Guest, on 13-09-2006 19:56
 
Dear Yumna. I loved your article; you have a witty way of narrating.  
 
I?ve seen a lot of people like the lady mentioned in your story.  
 
Actually, ?hijab? is still a controversial issue among intellectual and religious figures in our Islamic world. I don?t blame the lady for thinking that your ?hijab? comes from your Arabic background because it is, in fact, a Middle Eastern costume as well. It?s called ?hishma? which means chasteness, it was embraced before Islam by ?free" Arabic ladies those who are not enslaved and own themselves. Moreover, we definitely hold a great amount of responsibility for all this spread ?ignorance? about Muslims identity. Believe it or not, we do send the ?others? mixed messages that confuse them, leaving them thinking that ?Islam? is a race. For instance, they see girls who don?t wear scarves, have boyfriends, go clubs, and have few verses of Quran hanging on their golden necklaces! Few minutes later they see girls with scarves on, who refuse to have boyfriends or drink alcohol. The next day they see a worthy guy who prays and refuses to even verbally harm his neighbor, while on the other side a guy bombing the heck out of people left and right! All those people claim to be Muslims. Now, how on earth would one know whether this ?islam? is a religion or a race? He/she would absolutely think it?s a?relirace!?  
 
We really should practice Islam probably to reflect the real Islam, because people do tend to judge based on what they hear and see. I personally would be lost like them if I didn?t know Islam.  
 
Taima.  
 13 Written by Guest, on 15-09-2006 16:44
Thank you for your interesting perspectives!  
 
?I also think red scarfs are less religious than black ones? 
 
Ahem... I would say that?s a cultural statement :) by the way there?s some interesting research about why some European Muslim communities adopted dark colours when they used to be known once for colourful clothing.  
 
anyway, hijab is not meant to ?uglify? women or keep men in check. I think that conclusion is common because, well, in the past few centuries the male perspective has dominated religious discourse and I think that discourse was saturated with cultural beliefs.  
 
we were taught to think in dichotomies. hijab= modest; no hijab = not-good muslim; not-modest. So when these interpretations are salient, don?t be surprised to see ?wearing hijab and very tight everythig else?, because for some the hijab stays on for cultural factors and to maintain ?modesty? rather than conviction. and in all fairness, some start with the hijab and evolve at their own pace. 
 
a piece of fabric is not conducive to modesty. some of the most modest ppl i know are men and many are non muslim women. Like Taima said, it?s all in the actions.  
 
yumna
 14 GU
Written by Guest, on 15-10-2006 21:56
You know Yumna what you said about hijab being a statement could be quite problematic to many. :-) are you saying it's a mere symbol? what does that imply? 
Just wondering, I have nothing against it being a symbol I would go further and say I won't have a problem with anyone who says that it's not even an Islamic symbol... but I'm not sure if I understnd what you said about it being a statement.

Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.2